I had been planning for weeks. Researching, looking up information online, talking with people everywhere. I was working with everything I had on this. I was praying, preparing- I was going to be ready for everything. That fateful morning, I awoke, cool and confident while eager and excited. During the drive, I had nothing but excitement bubbling over with each mile passed. As I drove up the driveway, my excitement peaked- it was happening. As I stepped out of my car, one thought immediately took over:
RUN!
I was paralyzed right where I stood. Doom was approaching. It was all over now. But my brain was determined as well, screaming at me-
Get. Out. Of. There. NOW! Jump back in the car, get in gear, drive as fast as possible back home, and don't stop until then to freak out/throw up/pass out.
Still, I stayed, frozen in one spot. I was a helpless victim to the horrific evening set before me.
I'm talking about my first date with Kate of course.
********
Shortly after Kate and I had begun texting devotionals to each other each morning, we became best friends. I guess that's natural- there is something powerful about the bond between two souls sharing their walks with God with each other on a daily basis. While we were still hours apart, we became the closest of friends, more than her older sister and I had even been.
Then, as luck would have it, I started having more time to visit her at college. Since I had several other friends at her school, I made it a trip to see many people. Of course, Kate was the main person I would go see. We got along great! We would talk just with each for hours, coming away with more inside jokes than we could ever remember. I was glad to have a close friend- stepping into ministry from years of music school was interesting. She could relate, being a musical theatre major who had a heart for missions. It was this heart that led her to accept a position in a woman's crisis pregnancy center in the same state as Gondor, following her graduation in December 2011. She would still be hours away, but she was in a city I loved (let's call it "Rivendell") and I promised I would still visit her. My first chance came on a seemingly awkward day.
********
"So, guess who had a date on Valentine's day?!?"
Al looked blankly at me while BT just smirked and shook his head.
"With a girl too!" I added, just to make sure they got the joke.
"Yeah, Mitchell, not sure that counts. Just saying..."
"Well, true, but at least it was a date, even if it was just a best friend date."
Al breathed a sigh of relief- he was about to be even more depressed that the gay intern had had a date while he himself, thoroughly attracted to women, just rode his bike all day.
Yes, I had indeed been with Kate that day- Valentine's day of 2012. It was the only time I could get off from work- I promise. It wasn't intentional. I made that clear to her and she fully understood. But, we still made the most of it. We went to a park, made sandwiches, and enjoyed a lovely picnic. We then made each other big poster valentine's, thus "mocking" the holiday, and then played on a playground nearby. We followed this with a trip to a bookestore where we looked through a wedding fashion magazine.
Hindsight is 20/20 sometimes.
********
Kate had her own conversations following that non-date of Valentine's 2012. Her best friend, Beth, was possibly a little tired of hearing about me. She hadn't ever met me, but she knew one thing: I was the man Kate loved.
After I left Rivendell that 14th of February, Kate called up Beth to hash out her frustrations with her feelings.
"I like him, oh my gosh, I like him! But he's so not attracted to me and he's so not going to ever want to marry me, much less date me, much less every try to romanticize me! And yet I feel like he is flirting with me- but I know he doesn't realize it! He doesn't even have to try sometimes- Beth, he started talking about his dream to be a father one day and I about melted right there and kissed him! I wanna tell him so bad how I feel!"
"Well, why don't you?" Beth was getting a little sick of the "I love Mitchell" talks after a year or so.
"Because I know he doesn't like me. I know it. And I'd rather be friends at least than open my big mouth and ruin our friendship with my stupid feelings."
All the while they were talking, I was driving to Gondor, a good four hour drive. And my thoughts over that drive?
"I think I like her..."
********
Conversation after conversation after conversation. First BT, then my counselor, then- well no one. I only told those two about my feelings for Kate. I was confused. I mean, I had liked girls before, but never like this. I had been on some dates, tried pursuing girls- but nothing ever worked out. And it never really hurt me that much. But now- well, I wasn't sure what I felt. It was leaving me frustrated and depressed to be honest.
Both guys had the same advice- don't overthink it. Just let it be what it is and see what happens. If the feelings go away, then fine. If not, then do something about them. Also...
"Do you know if she feels the same about you?"
"No, she doesn't. I know she doesn't. And I don't want to ruin our friendship over friendship with my stupid feelings."
Who knew, though, it would only take two conversations to change both our minds.